Woman Gains Silver Star -- And Removal from Combat
What do you think of this story--
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/04/30/AR2008043003415.html
This isn't about Brown receiving the Silver Star. That is awesome!!! It's about her being pulled from her combat unit.
Pfc Monica Brown received the Silver Star in March for repeatedly risking her life on April 25, 2007, to treat wounded comrades. She is the second woman since WW II to receive the nation's third-highest combat medal.
Within a few days of her heroic acts, the Army pulled Brown out of the remote camp in Paktika province where she was serving with a cavalry unit apparently because Army restrictions on women in combat barred her from such missions.
I guess what concerns me about this is that it makes what Brown was doing--supporting a calvary regiment--seem unique. I understand the soldiers were fighting against the Taliban in Afghanistan, the fighting intensified, and she became a line medic. As a line medic, she spent days on combat operations--constant combat operations.
Was she pulled from the unit because of the intensity of the fighting? Is it okay for women to be in a firefight every other day or once a week, but not continuous, back-to-back missions ... at least not until they are found out? Thousands of our female service members support combat operations and are in harm's way on a daily basis. Apparently someone (a politician?) read about Brown and her Silver Star achievement and complained about her being attached to a combat unit? I think that whomever that was is very naive.
Women serving in noncombat roles throughout Iraq and Afghanistan face danger all the time. If the military pulled every woman who was serving in these countries and in danger, the size of the military and the success of its operations would be greatly reduced.
Once again we are denying our brave and courageous female service members the credit they deserve. I wish people would wake up and give credit where credit is due!!!

2 Comments:
I've heard a slightly different slant on the story, but do not know that it is true. SPC Brown was due for leave, just so happens, shortly after the event. She went on that leave as scheduled. She was then reassigned on her return to a clinic. Still, she was removed from the unit she had served with so well. In reality it's a largely meaningless point. There aren't "safe" areas. Rockets, mortars, IEDs, ambushes, all make any place vulnerable...The fact is that the men she treated that day are alive and (hopefully) well because of her actions. Without that they might well be dead.
The issue of women on the front lines has become one of insurmountable debate in our latest wars. Many of my non-combat MOS female friends served heroically in our last Iraq deployment. My closest friend earning a bronze star as an E-4 "commo" specialist who found herself driving the roads of Iraq on convoy security missions. She rarely did her actual job while in country. It is also very true that every Soldier, male or female, faces risk and danger simply by stepping foot overseas, regardless of leaving the confides of a base or camp. Time and time again, our brave sisters have shown they are able-bodied and more than capable of performing the skills we are all given in basic COMBAT training. I know I personally looking forward to my second deployment as a National Guard Soldier next year. I look forward to serving my country, my unit, and my fellow Soldiers, in whatever capacity I am asked, with the skills the Army has provided me. Keep leaning forward.
SSG V
Post a Comment
<< Home